A group of children practising a dance routine independently, showing how confidence changes in new situations.
August 31, 2026

Why Does My Child Seem Confident One Minute and Shy the Next?

Parents often describe their child as either "confident" or "shy." After more than twenty years working with children, I've come to think it's rarely that simple.

Parents often tell me one of two things.

“My child is really confident.”

Or…

“My child has no confidence.”

Whenever I hear that, I find myself thinking the same thing.

I don’t think confidence is quite that straightforward.

Over the years, I’ve realised that confidence changes.

Sometimes from one moment to the next.

A moment I notice every week

One of the clearest examples happens in dance class.

When children are learning a new routine, the teacher stands at the front of the room, demonstrating every movement.

Everyone follows along.

The room feels confident.

Then, at some point, the teacher steps back.

After all, they won’t be standing there during the performance.

That’s when something fascinating happens.

You see little side glances.

Children quickly checking what everyone else is doing.

Because suddenly, the reassurance has disappeared.

It’s such a tiny moment.

Most parents would probably never notice it.

But it says a lot.

Confidence depends on the situation

I’ve seen children who will happily perform in front of hundreds of people…

…but freeze when asked to introduce themselves to someone new.

I’ve seen children who chat confidently all morning…

…then suddenly become unsure when they’re learning something unfamiliar.

I’ve seen children who look nervous at the beginning of a class…

…and an hour later are laughing louder than anyone else.

That’s why I’ve stopped thinking of confidence as something children either have or don’t have.

I think it’s much more fluid than that.

Sometimes uncertainty looks like a lack of confidence

One of the easiest things to misread is hesitation.

A child who hangs back.

Looks around.

Watches everyone else first.

It’s tempting to think,

“They’re not confident.”

But often they’re simply gathering information.

They’re working out:

  • Is this safe?
  • Do I understand what I’m supposed to do?
  • Am I doing it the same as everyone else?

Once those questions are answered, many children relax almost immediately.

Confidence grows in lots of little moments

People often imagine confidence arrives all at once.

I’ve never really seen it happen that way.

More often, it grows quietly.

One successful experience.

One mistake that wasn’t a disaster.

One new friend.

One moment of thinking,

“Actually… I can do this.”

Those little moments gradually build into something much bigger.

The thing I've learnt

I don’t think children wake up one morning and suddenly become confident.

I think confidence changes depending on where they are, who they’re with and how safe they feel.

That’s good news.

Because it means confidence isn’t fixed.

It can grow.

Sometimes much more quickly than any of us expect.

Find out more about our

amazing performing arts classes here

Theatretrain Hitchin

Saturdays 

Hitchin Girls School

9.30am-12.30pm

Theatretrain Letchworth

Saturdays 

St Christopher’s School

9am-12pm

Theatretrain Stevenage

Saturdays 

Marriotts School

1.30pm-4.30pm

Theatretrain, a nationwide provider of weekend theatre schools for young people aged 4-18, specialises in weekly classes in acting, singing, and dancing. An emphasis is placed on learning valuable life skills such as confidence, empathy, courage, and resilience. If you know a child who loves to dance, act and sing or could do with a little confidence boost why not visit to find out what our performing arts classes can offer your child at one of our 80 locations across the UK.

Related Articles

What Are the Pros and Cons of Theatretrain?

What Are the Pros and Cons of Theatretrain?

If you’re thinking about Theatretrain for your child, I could give you a very long list of reasons why I think it’s brilliant. I’ve been part of Theatretrain for years, so obviously I’m not completely neutral! But I also don’t think it’s helpful to pretend there are no downsides. Every children’s activity has things that will suit some families brilliantly and things that won’t work for others. So if you’re trying to decide whether Theatretrain is right for your child, here are what I think are the genuine pros and cons.
Read more >
Is Theatretrain Right for Every Child? 7 Reasons It Might Not Be

Is Theatretrain Right for My Child? 7 Reasons It Might Not Be

I’m going to say something that probably sounds a bit odd coming from someone who runs Theatretrain. Theatretrain is not right for every child. And I think it’s really important to be honest about that. Of course, I want children to come along, enjoy it and hopefully stay with us for years. But I’d much rather tell you that Theatretrain might not be the right fit than persuade you to join and have your child miserable a few weeks later.
Read more >

Performing Arts School vs Dance School: Which Would Suit My Child?

If your child loves performing, you might find yourself choosing between a performing arts school and a dance school. At first glance, they can look quite similar. There may be music. There may be performances. There will probably be lots of energetic children coming out at the end! But the experience your child gets can be quite different. Neither is necessarily better than the other. The important question is: Which one is the better fit for your child?
Read more >